Indonesian democracy is one of the Asia-Pacific’s most remarkable recent accomplishments. The turn this giant country made from autocracy under Suharto to a system of ‘one person, one vote’ is truly breathtaking. Indonesia has been transformed.

 

At the same time, Jakarta is well aware that stable democracy is not an easily-won goal; the country cannot rest on its laurels. Indeed, Indonesians can learn an important lesson from their colleagues in Thailand; strengthen the institutions of democracy when you have the opportunity, and don’t wait until crisis comes knocking.

A woman in Jakarta casts her ballot in Indonesia's 2009 presidential election, the second since the fall of the Suharto. (Photo: Flickr user 'Isafrancesca')

During the Cold War, Southeast Asia was led by a handful of autocratic strong leaders – Suharto, Mahathir, Marcos, Lee Kuan Yew, and arguably the

King of Thailand. For the cold war powers, as long as these leaders could control their polity, society and economy, their Machiavellian nature was of no consequence. Supported by the cold war architecture, these men transformed their countries from post-colonial commodity based economies into today’s ‘tigers’ of Asia. Foreign investment poured in, infrastructure was built and countries were brought into the modern era.

Unfortunately, for the most part, these men failed to develop of institutions that would underpin the inevitable evolution to democracy. Such institutions as did exist were undercut or subjugated to support autocratic rule. As the region’s strongmen left the stage in different ways, more political space was created, and democratic reforms put into place. Thailand pulled the military out of direct involvement in politics in the early1990′s (not without some serious violence and strife), and instituted a new constitution.

But as the horrifying events in Bangkok earlier this year proved, Thailand’s institutions, such as the courts and the electoral commission, were not sufficiently developed to resolve violent conflict and crisis. These institutions had not earned the independence and trust of the Thai people.

The Philippines remains similarly precarious. According to pre-polling for the Philippines 2010 election, candidate Aquino had what appeared to be an insurmountable lead. Luckily, the pre-polling was correct. But had a hundred or more of the new automated voting machines used in the May elections failed to function, and had candidate Aquino not won by a definable margin, his supporters had in place a detailed plan to take to the streets. That this plan even existed is enough to demonstrate continuing Filipino mistrust of their electoral process.

Fast forward to the next Indonesian elections in 2014. What if the candidates competing for President run a very close and disputed race? Are Indonesia’s courts and electoral bodies prepared for that situation? And what if, at the time of the 2014 election, certain candidates have access to sources of hard power, either via the military or via private business?

These are serious questions that demand consideration by Indonesian leaders and civil society.

Now is the right time to invest in strengthening key democratic institutions in Indonesia, and indeed around the region. Strengthening institutions would secure Indonesia’s nascent democracy and the rights of its deserving citizens. Indonesia will do well to learn the hard lessons of Thailand.

Author: Ernest Z. Bower, CSIS

Ernest Z. Bower is Senior Adviser and Director of the Southeast Asia Program, Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington

  1. Indonesia’s growing economic power
  2. Thailand’s Songkran crisis of 2009
  3. Thailand’s political crisis has broader ramifications

Read more:
Lessons for Indonesia from Thailand: Strengthen institutions before the crisis

About the author

East Asia Forum provides a platform for the best in East Asian analysis, research and policy comment on the Asia Pacific region and world affairs.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Get notified of our weekly selection of news

You May Also Like

Energy transition and emerging markets

The push for carbon neutrality and improved environmental sustainability places a unique set of pressures on emerging markets. The essential question is: how can such economies fulfil their economic potential while at the same time striving for net zero?

Indonesia, the land of the unicorns

GoTo’s strong performance indicates the strength of Indonesia’s digital economy, which is home to eight other tech unicorns. The company is the second unicorn listed on the Indonesian Stock Exchange.

Which emerging markets are looking to bolster electric vehicle production?

Thailand is not alone in the region when it comes to building up its EV capacity, with Indonesia also unveiling a series of measures in recent years.