Connect with us

Ghosts of the Asian financial crisis still haunt Indonesia

In 1996, Southeast Asia was celebrating its ‘economic miracle’ as the World Bank lauded the region’s spectacular growth.



In 1996, Southeast Asia was celebrating its ‘economic miracle’ as the World Bank lauded the region’s spectacular growth.

Tackling middle income challenges was the focus of an IMF–ASEAN conference in Jakarta. The mood was ebullient. Less than a year later on 2 July 1997, Thailand floated the baht, triggering the Asian financial crisis.In Indonesia, the rupiah lost 85 per cent of its value, GDP fell by almost 15 per cent and the banking crisis became the most expensive in history, costing over 50 per cent of GDP.

And this simple accounting does not capture the human costs of the crisis.

After decades of economic success, it was not surprising that denial, the first stage of grief, persisted for months. But by 1998, the scale and severity of the Asian crisis was clear.

An ANU conference was aptly headlined ‘East Asia in Crisis: From Being a Miracle to Needing One!’.

For Indonesia, the road to recovery would be a challenging journey, lasting from 1997 until 2003.

For the two-thirds of Indonesia’s current population who were not yet born or who were still children in 1997, much of what is ‘remembered’ today is folklore.

Yet the crisis still resonates. It triggered the collapse of political and economic institutions that delivered remarkable growth for 30 years. Rebuilding these institutions and a sound economic framework — albeit redesigned for a middle-income democracy — remains a challenge today.The recovery of states across Asia following the financial crisis was shaped by the maturity of their political institutions.

All countries affected experienced political change in one form or another. For many, political change provided a mandate for difficult economic reforms. For Indonesia, political change meant a mandate to build democracy.

The end of the Suharto regime signalled the end of political legitimacy based on delivering high growth. Economic reform was subsidiary to building a new democracy.

Indonesia’s economic reform program was almost entirely off track for the duration of the 1999–2001 Gus Dur administration. The economy suffered and, in 2001, Indonesia was on the edge of crisis once again.

Only after the impeachment of Gus Dur and the arrival of the Megawati administration did economic recovery begin to take shape.The crisis and changing political institutions — including a dramatic decentralisation of political and fiscal power — meant that the existing economic institutions had become redundant, if not damaged irreparably by the crisis.

Under Suharto, economic policy was driven by a small group of key ministers and highly capable policymakers. The civil service was designed to implement not develop these policies and its structure was organised along military lines.

Political and economic reforms over the seven years of the crisis were grafted onto this existing structure. With the economy in free-fall, there was no scope to think about a new system, let alone create one. But Indonesia’s centralised economic decision making did begin to diffuse to a broad range of players.

Some temporary agencies were set up to help deliver reforms. The Indonesia Bank Restructuring Agency was established to bypass the central bank and to enable a more business-oriented approach to bank restructuring. A new commercial debt restructuring task force (JITF) was also implemented to act as a facilitator and mediator between creditors and debtors. But these agencies had mixed success.

Indonesia also tried to work around the old system by setting up new permanent agencies. It established the Corruption Eradication Commission, an anti-monopoly agency (KPPU) and the Commercial Court, among others. But these agencies have, to varying degrees, struggled and have not been able to set Indonesia in a new direction.

Indonesia enacted legislation on state finance, the treasury and audit processes, designed to be the foundation of the new economy. These were important steps forward. But the effective implementation of these laws remains on the agenda today.

The crisis has left a lasting legacy on a range of economic policies. For macroeconomic policy, fears still linger that if the rupiah weakens, it may repeat a crisis-like free-fall. But a weaker rupiah, along with lower interest rates, would have actually supported growth and job creation at various points in time since the financial crisis.

Likewise, the memory of the near 100 per cent debt-to-GDP ratio during the crisis has at times fuelled undue concern about relatively modest public debt and led the government to be overly stringent in tightening fiscal policy.In terms of infrastructure, no effective replacement for the Suharto-era system has been developed.


Author: David Nellor,

Source: Ghosts of the Asian financial crisis still haunt Indonesia | East Asia Forum

East Asia Forum provides a platform for the best in East Asian analysis, research and policy comment on the Asia Pacific region and world affairs.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply


Asia’s slow rate of vaccination is a thorn in the region’s economic recovery

Southeast Asia has been hit badly. Daily infections for Indonesia, Thailand, Vietnam are at their worst, on a seven-day moving average. The Philippines and Malaysia are not far off their daily infection peaks reached in the second quarter of 2021.



Last week was tough for the Asia-Pacific region. Many countries responded to stubbornly elevated daily infections by extending or tightening social distancing measures.

Continue Reading


TAT expects 850 billion baht ($25.7 bln) in tourism revenue after successful reopening

The Tourism Authority of Thailand (TAT) has set this year’s revenue target at 850 billion baht, 300 billion of which will come from 3 million international visitors and the remaining 550 billion from the domestic market.



Ko Samed deserted pier

BANGKOK (NNT) – Following the launch of the Phuket Sandbox tourism scheme on July 1st this year, many foreign tourists moved by the warm hospitality of the people of Phuket, are looking forward to visiting other provinces, such as Chiang Mai and Bangkok.

Continue Reading

Most Viewed

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 14,162 other subscribers